• Hüppa sisu juurde
  • Hüppa päise menüü juurde
  • Hüppa jaluse menüü juurde
Eesti Panga logo
LigipääsetavusEesti keeles
Eesti keeles
  • Annual Report
  • Estonian Economy and Monetary Policy
  • Financial Stability Review
  • Labour Market Review
  • Financing of the Economy
  • Estonian Competitiveness Report
  • Working Papers
  • Occasional Papers
  • Climate-related financial disclosures
  • Varia
  • Archive
researchMerike Kukk

3/2025 Triin Bulõgina, Merike Kukk. How the large-scale early withdrawals from private pension plans were used: insights from young adults

Working Papers of Eesti Pank 3/2025

The final version of the article is published in the Baltic Journal of Economics, DOI https://doi.org/10.1080/1406099X.2025.2578923

This paper investigates the spending and financial behaviour of young adults in Estonia after they withdrew their pension savings from the previously mandatory second pillar. When the option was first implemented in 2021, one pension saver in five exercised it. We use account-level data to explore changes in spending and investing behaviour, and in bank savings and debt holdings among those withdrawing. Regression analysis of differences in growth rates over various time horizons between matched samples reveals that early withdrawals have substantial short-term impacts on spending and the financial situation of those making the withdrawal, but these effects subside within one year. Over 55% of the money withdrawn had been spent within three months and over 40% was used for repaying debts. The findings indicate that those who withdrew savings from their pension accounts did not adopt alternative retirement saving strategies, suggesting that early withdrawals worsen their long-term financial outlook.

JEL Codes: D12, D14, G51, H55

Keywords: Pension savings, second pillar, early withdrawals, young adults, spending, loans, investments

DOI: 10.23656/25045520/032025/0221

Corresponding author’s email: [email protected]

The views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official views of Eesti Pank or the Eurosystem.

Failid

  • PDF failitüüpi kujutav ikoon3/2025 Triin Bulõgina, Merike Kukk. How the large-scale early withdrawals from private pension plans were used: insights from young adults
Publikatsiooni 3/2025 Triin Bulõgina, Merike Kukk. How the large-scale early withdrawals from private pension plans were used: insights from young adults kaanepilt

Contacts

  • +372 668 0719
  • [email protected]
  • Contacts
  • Processing of personal data

Info

  • Frequently asked questions

Social Media

  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Flickr
  • LinkedIn

References

  • European Central Bank
  • Eesti Pank Museum
  • Finantsinspektsioon
  • Other central banks

E-sources

  • E-shop